Accused allegedly tried to kill estranged husband three times before mushroom meal

Posted by
Check your BMI

Erin Patterson has been charged with trying to kill her ex-husband at least three times in the years before she allegedly fed his family a lunch of deadly mushrooms.

The new details were revealed in court documents, as the 49-year-old woman faced court on Friday charged with three counts of murder and five of attempted murder.

She is accused of killing her former in-laws, Don and Gail Patterson, both 70, and Gail's sister Heather Wilkinson, 66.

READ MORE: Victorians warned to brace for extreme pollen levels

toonsbymoonlight

All three died in hospital days after consuming a meal at Patterson's Leongatha home, in South Gippsland, on July 29 this year.

Patterson showed no emotion as she sat in the custody dock.

She is also accused of the attempted murder of her ex-husband Simon on at least four occasions, dating back to 2021, court documents revealed.

Police allege Patterson first attempted to murder Simon between November 16 and 17, 2021.

She is then accused of her ex-husband's attempted murder in 2022, between May 25 and 27, and on September 6.

It's further alleged she attempted to kill Simon at the July 29 lunch.

READ MORE: Eastern Freeway crash Porsche driver Richard Pusey wanted over court order breaches

The fifth attempted murder charge relates to Wilkinson's husband Ian, 68, who spent close to two months in hospital critically ill after the lunch and is still in recovery.

Media filled three rows of seating as Patterson appeared in Latrobe Valley Magistrates Court on Friday morning, wearing a beige jumper and reading glasses, for a brief hearing.

Flanked by two custody officers in safety glasses, Patterson showed no emotion as she sat in the dock on the side of the courtroom.

Prosecutor Acting Sergeant Greg Ellis asked the court for 20 weeks to prepare and serve a brief of evidence on Patterson's lawyers.

"There needs to be analysis of computer equipment seized yesterday," he told the court.

Magistrate Tim Walsh appeared annoyed and questioned why it would take "20 weeks to analyse computer equipment in a triple murder, where the informant is confident he had enough evidence to charge this lady yesterday?"

READ MORE: Notorious leaf-stealing koala strikes nursery again – this time with accomplices

Defence lawyer Bill Doogue, who said he had been engaged with Patterson "for a while", agreed to the delay.

"It seems to be based on a lot of analysis that we haven't received and hasn't even been completed, which is why they're asking for extra time," he said.

Walsh explained to Patterson that the matters they were discussing were administrative.

"So don't be too concerned alright, the important thing is this matter progresses through the system as fast as possible," he told her.

"OK," she replied, nodding her head.

Doogue said evidence seemed to be based on analysis not received.

Both the defence and prosecution tried to move the matter to Melbourne, but Walsh decided to set down the next hearing at the Morwell court.

"I imagine the materials are going to be voluminous, and that it does go to Melbourne so that a particular magistrate can manage the matter," Walsh said.

READ MORE: Week-long soaking set to drench millions

A courtroom sketch of Erin Patterson.

Doogue said Patterson did not have any custody management issues.

The magistrate told Patterson there was no application for bail as he did not have the power to grant it.

If she applies for bail, that will need to be heard in the Supreme Court at a later date.

The accused triple murderer was silent as she was escorted out of the courtroom.

Patterson was remanded in custody and will next face court via video link from prison on May 3 next year.