Benzema’s defamation suit against top French minister is dismissed

Posted by
Check your BMI

Karim Benzema’s defamation lawsuit against French Interior Minister Gérald Darmanin, who claimed the French football star was “notoriously linked” to the Muslim Brotherhood, has been dismissed.

Benzema filed the complaint last month, following multiple remarks by Darmanin linking the striker to the Islamist organization after he publicly backed Palestinians in Gaza.

In the lawsuit, the footballer said he “never had the slightest connection with the Muslim Brotherhood organization, nor to [my] knowledge with anyone who claims to be a member of it,” and alleged he has been “instrumentalized in political games” because of his fame.

But on Tuesday, the Court of Justice of the Republic, a court for lawsuits against members of the government, dismissed the complaint.

The court found that Darmanin’s remarks “do not impute to [Benzema] any fact that is likely to undermine his honour or his reputation,” according to a statement by public prosecutor of the Court of Cassation Rémy Heitz. The decision is not subject to appeal, he added.

In October, Darmanin, a right-leaning minister and a longtime hard-liner on security issues and secularism, caused a media storm when he claimed that Benzema, the 2022 Ballon D’or winner, had ties to the Muslim Brotherhood, an Islamist party which some Middle Eastern countries consider to be a terrorist group.

“Benzema is notoriously linked with the Muslim Brotherhood, we all know it,” the French minister said in an interview on French conservative TV broadcaster CNews. Darmanin later doubled down on the accusations, saying Benzema had “made the extremely selective choice of using the same discourse as the Muslim Brotherhood” on social media.

Benzema’s lawyer, Hugues Vigier, denied that there was any link between Benzema and the Muslim Brotherhood, before filing the lawsuit in January.

Benzema, a former Real Madrid superstar who plays for the Saudi-based Al-Ittihad football club, is a practicing Muslim and has publicly expressed his support for Palestinians in Gaza under fire by Israel.

The football star has a history of legal battles. In 2021, he was found guilty of conspiring to blackmail a fellow French footballer with a sex tape. A court handed him a a one-year suspended jail term and ordered him to pay a €75,000 fine.

Vigier, Benzema’s lawyer, could not immediately be reached for comment.

Nicolas Camut contributed reporting.