Warning: This article contains spoilers for this week’s edition of And Just Like That.
Things took an emotional turn in the latest instalment of And Just Like That, when Nicole Ari Parker’s character Lisa Todd Wexley was left grieving after the death of her father.
Much of the episode centred around Lisa’s feelings of guilt over not being there at the end of her father’s life, and the rest of the characters later joined her at the funeral.
However, this latest development in the And Just Like That storyline has left some viewers scratching their heads… namely because Lisa had already said her father was dead shortly after the character was first introduced.
In episode two of the Sex And The City revival, Charlotte confided in Lisa that she was struggling after the death of Carrie’s husband, Mr Big.
LTW responded: “I was the exact same way when I lost my dad last year. I could see my rings literally shaking on my hands while I was trying to be so strong…”
@brettanthonycollins How did they not catch this?! #ajlt#satc#floptiktok#ltw#viralvideos#fyp#fypシ
the writers forgetting they had already killed off LTW’s dad in season one #AndJustLikeThatpic.twitter.com/zX5ptypuIl
— Shane 🍊 (@shaaneoliver) July 5, 2025
Did the writers of #AndJustLikeThat forget Lisa’s dad was already dead?? She told Charlotte that in season 1. lmaooo. This show is so bad
— yasmin (@yasmin86) July 5, 2025
Wait… Lisa's father was already dead (from a previous episode)??? #AndJustLikeThat#AJLT
— Brett (@Rynehelm) July 5, 2025
Wasn't Lisa's father already dead in a previous season? Now he has been resurrected and killed off again?? And what was with Herbert's terrible delivery of the news??#ajlt#AndJustLikeThat#andjustlikethatseason3
— The Watcher (@TellyTubbo) July 4, 2025
Wait just realised Lisa already confirmed in S1 that her Father was already dead😭 these writers… pic.twitter.com/eIWh0DNJ52
— RealHousewivesRanked! (@RankedReal) July 4, 2025
So the writers of #AndJustLikeThat hate writing the show as much as viewers hate watching it because how do they write an episode about Lisa’s dad dying yet mentioned him being dead already the season before? #AJLThttps://t.co/mxo1lBQd5h
— Branden Lee (@Brandeness) July 4, 2025
LTW’s dad dying twice pic.twitter.com/4qOuszGbrq
— Teresa’s 5th Dorter (@The_CinemaFreak) July 6, 2025
Didn’t LTW’s father die already? In Season 1??
#AndJustLikeThatpic.twitter.com/q6VOuxdMzk
— Simy (@Simy_78) July 4, 2025
Exacerbating matters even further is the fact that in between Lisa’s dad’s first and second deaths, viewers even got the chance to meet him, with Star Wars favourite Billy Dee Williams playing him in an episode where LTW and her husband Herbert host a dinner party in honour of their wedding anniversary…
sooooooo, lisa's dad was already d3@d on szn 1 ep 2
i guess he reincarnated for a dinner party lisa hosted in szn 2
now we're on szn 3 ep 6 and it's lisa's dad's funeral
cancel "and just like that" pls
put us outta our misery pic.twitter.com/qnccVVF5r6— Atlanta Cowboy Carter July 14 🐝 (@naeeve_) July 4, 2025
Lisa Todd's father died…twice?
She told Charlotte in S1 she lost her dad "last year". He came to dinner in S2 👻 (Billy Dee Williams). Then he died, again, in S3?
Did ChatGPT write these episodes? 😬 #AJLTpic.twitter.com/VS046FIgGW
— ʙᴇʟʟᴀᴅᴏɴɴᴀ (@canyou_sonicme) July 6, 2025
#andjustlikethatseason3 is scraping so hard for storylines that they've had to re-kill LTW's dad! (he was dead in S1, but they resurrected him for S2).
— Steacy Curry 💎 (@SteacyC) July 4, 2025
This isn’t the first time that the Sex And The City revival has lost track of characters who are and are not dead, though.
Early on in the reboot, Harry referred to his mother having been “dead for 10 years” – although when he first met Charlotte in Sex And The City, almost 20 years earlier, he told his future wife that his mum was already dead, and that he’d vowed to her on her deathbed that he would marry a Jewish woman (leading to Charlotte converting to Judaism).
MORE SEX AND THE CITY:
