OPINION | What lies beneath the DA’s votes?

Check your BMI

By Dr Thapelo Tselapedi

Though Mashaba’s ActionSA is the horse that had tongues wagging at this year’s local government elections, the Democratic Alliance (DA) is undoubtedly one of the biggest winners of the 2026 local government elections.

Not only is its growing national footprint uneven, however, but its ability, or lack thereof, to bridge the political divide might also constrain its ability to make inroads beyond the party’s electoral voter base.

Let us take, for instance, the DA’s electoral fortunes in the City of Cape Town, the City of Johannesburg and the City of Tshwane.

In the City of Cape Town, the DA currently sits at 56,64% of the electorate, with 1,284,875 voters. However, in 2021, it sat at 58,33% of the electorate with 1,061,657 voters and then in 2016, it sat at 66,61% of the electorate with 1,664,514 voters. This trajectory shows a gradual decline in their voter base.

In the City of Tshwane, the DA currently sits at 34,37% of the electorate, with 615,490 voters. However, in 2021, it sat at 32.03% of the electorate with 431,042 voters and then in 2016, it sat at 43,15% of the electorate with 762, 190 voters.

In the city of Johannesburg, the DA currently sits at 34,98% of the electorate with 860,438 voters. In 2021, it sat at 26.14 % of the electorate with 482, 653 voters; in 2016, it sat at 38,41% of the electorate with 964, 855 voters.

Given the foregoing, it’s quite evident that Mmusi Maimane’s DA (2015-2019) was able to bring black voters into the DA’s electoral base. However, John Steenhuisen’s DA (2019-2026) plummeted the party’s electoral fortunes. Largely running with Helen Zille as the face of the DA’s campaign in 2026, the party could not claw back the percentage points Mmusi’s DA achieved during his tenure.

Besides this oscillating feature of the DA’s electoral fortunes, this says something about the DA’s external positioning among the electorate. But there’s also something to be said about its internal party logic.

For instance, it is evident that a black leader and a white woman are the two subjectivities that are palatable to an electorate beyond the traditional voter base of the DA. However, while these subjectivities may resonate with the party’s external influence, internally, given the DA’s internal leadership rupture against Mmusi Maimane, the DA’s party leadership struggles with a black leader at the helm.

Accordingly, in the absence of similarly leading subjectivities in the DA, the use of Zille as the face of the DA’s campaign seems to be a desperate measure, indicating a lack of long-term thinking about identifying a leader that reconciles the party’s external electoral appeal and its internal party dynamic.

This lack of long-term thinking might damage the party’s prospects as the country enters its second phase of democracy.

This phase is characterised by a move away from a dominant-party system to a multiparty system, in which bipartisan politics will be the hallmark of coalition systems. In other words, the ability to bridge the political divide will be a skill that party political leadership must nurture moving forward.

Opposing political parties need to nurture leaders that can identify common ground through compromise and solve problems across party and policy lines to gain broad support in municipal councils.

These developments certainly make the process of governing a lot more precarious, dynamic and subjective, but they also provide the opportunity for the country’s political leaders to move away from partisan thinking that characterised the dominant party system.

While Zille may have helped the DA make inroads in these elections, giving them some time to sort out their housekeeping issues, one can only hope that the DA is alive to these developments.

 

Dr Thapelo Tselapedi is a Senior Lecturer in the Department of Political Studies at UWC.